Alloy vs Belmar Pharmacy

Vial Take

Both Alloy and Belmar carry clean federal records across FDA, OIG, DEA, and HIPAA checks, and both leave you doing more homework than you'd like on the supply chain side since neither discloses pharmacy partners publicly. The biggest split is where each earns its credibility: Belmar's 30-year track record and PCAB accreditation push it to an 83 trust score and make it one of the more rigorously credentialed compounding pharmacies Vial tracks, while Alloy's 75 score rests on something Belmar can't match, which is actual physician disclosure with board-certified OB/GYNs specializing in menopause. If you're sourcing compounded medications, Belmar's accreditation is the stronger anchor; if you want to know who's signing off on your protocol, Alloy gives you that visibility and Belmar doesn't.

Biggest Differences

1. 1
   PCAB accreditation
   Belmar Pharmacy is PCAB-accredited (the most rigorous compounding-pharmacy quality standard in the US); Alloy is not.
2. 2
   Geographic reach
   Belmar Pharmacy is available in 46 states compared to Alloy's 0, which may decide the question before any other signal if you're outside Alloy's footprint.
3. 3
   Trust Score gap (8 points)
   Belmar Pharmacy scores 83/100 to Alloy's 75/100, a 8-point spread driven by the differences below.