VIAL TRUST COMPARISON

Belmar Pharmacy vs CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy

Biggest Differences

Trust Score gap (21 points)
Belmar Pharmacy scores 83/100 to CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy's 62/100, a 21-point spread driven by the differences below.
PCAB accreditation
Belmar Pharmacy is PCAB-accredited (the most rigorous compounding-pharmacy quality standard in the US); CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy is not.
Geographic reach
Belmar Pharmacy is available in 46 states compared to CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy's 0, which may decide the question before any other signal if you're outside CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy's footprint.

Belmar Pharmacy

Compounding Pharmacy

83/ 100

Meets baseline compliance standards.

Moderate· 5/9

Full report →

CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy

Compounding Pharmacy

62/ 100

Gaps in verifiable compliance data.

Low· 3/9

Full report →

Generated by Vial · May 17, 2026

Signal-by-Signal

Compliance Comparison

Signal	Belmar PharmacyA	CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy	Edge
NPI Registration	✗ Not Found	✗ Not Found	Same
FDA Enforcement	✓ No Actions Found	✓ No Actions Found	Same
PCAB Accreditation	✓ Accredited	✗ Not Accredited	Belmar
LegitScript	✗ Not Certified	✗ Not Certified	Same
Vial Trust Score	83/100	62/100	Belmar

Vial Analysis

Our Assessment

Belmar Pharmacy

Best for

Patients requiring compounded medications
Patients prioritizing compliance and transparency

Main strength

↑ PCAB-accredited pharmacy partner

Main caution

⚠ NPI registration not confirmed in federal registry

CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy

Best for

Main strength

↑ No active FDA enforcement actions on record

Main caution

⚠ NPI registration not confirmed in federal registry

Belmar Pharmacy has thicker public disclosure across the signals Vial tracks. Neither score is a verdict on quality of care, but the gap is worth understanding before you pay.

Comparison reflects publicly disclosed federal and state records only. Vial does not audit clinical quality or patient outcomes.

Provider A

Belmar Pharmacy

DeliveryTelehealth Only

Price TierMid

HQLakewood, CO

Services: TRT, HRT, Peptides +1

Profile →Report →

Provider B

CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy

HQCharlotte, NC

Profile →Report →

Want to run a full compliance report on either provider?

Belmar Pharmacy Report →|CareFirst Specialty Pharmacy Report →

Other matchups

Related comparisons

Comparison based on public federal and state records including NPI Registry, FDA enforcement database, and PCAB accreditation directory. Updated weekly. Not a medical endorsement.