VIAL
Vial›Compare›Alloy vs Defy Medical
VIAL TRUST COMPARISON

Alloy vs Defy Medical

Biggest Differences

  1. Pharmacy disclosure
    Defy Medical publishes its compounding partners (Empower Pharmacy, Olympia Pharmacy), so you can verify the supply chain; Alloy does not name a pharmacy partner publicly.
  2. Physician disclosure
    Defy Medical publishes named clinical leadership you can research before signing up; Alloy describes its clinical team in aggregate without identifying specific physicians.
  3. Geographic reach
    Defy Medical is available in 48 states compared to Alloy's 0, which may decide the question before any other signal if you're outside Alloy's footprint.

Alloy

Telehealth Platform
75/ 100
Meets baseline compliance standards.
Moderate Confidence· 5/9
Full report →
vs

Defy Medical

Telehealth Platform
75/ 100
Meets baseline compliance standards.
Moderate Confidence· 5/9
Full report →
Generated by Vial · May 14, 2026
Share
Signal-by-Signal

Compliance Comparison

SignalAlloyDefy MedicalEdge
NPI Registration✗ Not Found✗ Not FoundSame
FDA Enforcement✓ No Actions Found✓ No Actions FoundSame
PCAB Accreditation✗ Not Accredited✗ Not AccreditedSame
LegitScript✗ Not Certified✗ Not CertifiedSame
Physician Credentials✓ Listed✓ ListedSame
Vial Trust Score75/10075/100Same
Vial Analysis

Our Assessment

Alloy
Best for
    Main strength
    ↑ No active FDA enforcement actions on record
    Main caution
    ⚠ NPI registration not confirmed in federal registry
    Defy Medical
    Best for
      Main strength
      ↑ No active FDA enforcement actions on record
      Main caution
      ⚠ NPI registration not confirmed in federal registry

      Both providers show similar public records. Your choice may come down to treatment type, state availability, and pricing.

      Comparison reflects publicly disclosed federal and state records only. Vial does not audit clinical quality or patient outcomes.

      Provider A

      Alloy

      DeliveryOnline Only
      Price TierMid
      Provider B

      Defy Medical

      DeliveryHybrid
      Price TierMid
      HQTampa, FL
      Services: TRT, HRT, Peptides +2

      Want to run a full compliance report on either provider?

      VIAL

      Related

      Other comparisons featuring these providers

      Alloy
      Hims & Hers
      13-point gapCompare →
      Defy Medical
      Hims & Hers
      13-point gapCompare →
      Alloy
      LifeForce
      6-point gapCompare →
      Defy Medical
      LifeForce
      6-point gapCompare →
      Alloy
      Marek Health
      5-point gapCompare →
      Defy Medical
      Marek Health
      5-point gapCompare →

      Comparison based on public federal and state records including NPI Registry, FDA enforcement database, and PCAB accreditation directory. Updated weekly. Not a medical endorsement.